Quick answer
Should I sell my inherited sign collection directly or at auction?
Compare your expected take-home amount, pickup responsibility, and time to payment. Ask for a direct purchase offer and compare it with the likely auction proceeds after seller costs.
Comparing what you receive from each sale route
Inventory the room and separate the likely pre-1970 pieces for a closer look. Ask whether a proposed offer covers all identified signs or only specific pieces.
Photograph each sign front and back and number the images. Give special attention to signs still hanging and identify any deadline for clearing the property.
For an auction, ask about seller commission, reserve, transport, insurance, catalog timing, and payment. For a direct offer, agree which items are included and who handles removal.
Give the sign its own record before you put a price on it. For an inherited sign collection, write down the full wording and the condition of the parts you can see. Label each observation as something you saw, something a previous owner told you, or something you found in a dated source. When you get a possible match, that record makes it easier to see which details agree and which ones still need an explanation.
Compare the proceeds and terms
Start with a completed sale that matches the piece closely. If you have a group of signs, including a large service station piece and several smaller panels, make a side-by-side note with the dimensions, number of visible faces or pieces, mounting method, and condition. For signs sold as part of a group, check whether a price was assigned to the individual piece. Keep the sale date and the link so you can revisit the comparison.
Read how the price is reported before you compare two results. A winning bid, a price including buyer’s premium, and the amount the seller receives describe different parts of a transaction. If the sales do not say which figure is shown, record that as unknown. For a direct purchase, confirm which pieces and services are included in the offer, such as collection from a specific location.
If you find only one promising comparison, list the most important difference in a sentence. A damaged face, a missing ring, a different scale, or an unverified date can make a sale less useful for pricing. A documented difference is more helpful than applying an arbitrary discount. Keep one or two references to send Tom with your photos if they clarify what you own.
A seller’s example
Imagine an owner finds a group of signs, including a large service station piece and several smaller panels. They want to know what they have and decide whether to sell, so they save a few reference photos and measure their piece first. A family receives an auction estimate and a direct offer. They list the expenses they would actually pay and compare expected net proceeds and dates. The family can choose based on its priorities and the uncertainty in each route.
The owner keeps the original photos and the messages about the sign together. Before deciding, they confirm what the buyer has seen, what is included, and when payment and pickup would happen. If a family member has a different recollection about the piece’s age or origin, they include that uncertainty in the description. This example is illustrative.
What to send Tom
- Photograph each sign front and back and number the images. Give special attention to signs still hanging and identify any deadline for clearing the property.
- One straight-on photo of each accessible face. Include a wide shot that shows the whole piece.
- Height and width, with the face and frame measured separately when applicable.
- Close-ups of any maker’s line, mounting holes, damage, and known repairs.
- Your city, whether you are selling one item or a collection, and any timing or pickup constraints.
Frequently asked questions
Is the posted auction result what the seller took home?
Ask how buyer’s premium, seller commission, and other expenses are accounted for. The headline total can differ from the seller’s proceeds.
Should I request a written list of what’s included?
Yes. Confirm which items, accessories, and handling or pickup arrangements are covered.
What if I want to keep one sign?
Mention it before requesting a group offer. Keep it clearly identified outside the pieces you are offering.
What photos should I text Tom first?
Begin with the full face of a group of signs, including a large service station piece and several smaller panels. Add the reverse, dimensions, and one close-up of markings or damage. If you have multiple pieces, give each one a number and keep the corresponding photos together.
Can I ask for an offer if I don’t know the year?
Yes. Tell Tom what you know about the piece and where it was found. Antique Sign Guy focuses on signs made before 1970. Clear views of the construction and maker’s print can help him decide whether your sign fits.
Is the highest auction result a reasonable asking price?
Start with completed sales closest to your individual signs in construction, size, and condition. An exceptional result can show what makes a particular example special. Check what the number includes and how closely the piece matches yours.
How do I sell directly to Tom?
Text 916-817-9625 with photos, your city, and the approximate size. Say that you’re looking to sell. If there is a fit, ask which pieces the offer covers and confirm payment and pickup terms before accepting.
What if my photos show damage or old repairs?
Include them. A wide photo shows how the piece displays, and a close-up lets someone see the scope of the wear. Mention any known repainting, replacement parts, cracks, or extra holes. That helps Tom make an offer with fewer unknowns.
Ask Tom for a direct purchase offer
Have a sign you think was made before 1970? Text Tom at 916-817-9625 with photos, approximate dimensions, and your city. If the sign is still mounted or you’re clearing an estate, say so up front. Tell Tom you’d like to sell so he can review it as a possible purchase.
Related guide and auction reference
Read a related Antique Sign Guy guide for more help identifying or documenting your piece.
A published auction total can include buyer’s premium. AntiqueAdvertising.com explains that its price guide shows the total paid by the buyer. Ask the auctioneer for your expected net proceeds and compare that figure with the terms of a direct offer.


