Quick answer
What is my old Coca-Cola sign worth?
To estimate the value of an old Coca-Cola sign, identify its exact design, size, material, and condition. Compare a curved button with other buttons of the same diameter and design. Use similarly matched results for flat tin or porcelain signs.
Learn how to identify a Coca-Cola button, tin sign or porcelain sign and find comparable sales for the exact version.
Identify the shape and material
Record the slogan and dimensions. If it’s a round convex button, measure the diameter. On a rectangular sign, photograph the border and any maker’s print toward the edge. Take a close-up of a worn spot and a photo of the back so the surface and mounting style are visible.
Date the item as well as the logo
Coca-Cola imagery has been reused. Compare the exact wording, dimensions, print, and mounting hardware with a documented example. An old-looking logo is one clue. A maker’s line, a period photo, or a record of where the sign came from can help narrow the date further.
Use comparable sales
Look for sold examples with the same material and shape. Compare fading, rust, chips, repainting, and added holes. A high asking price for another Coke sign tells you little if the sign has a different design or construction.
Make a photo record a buyer can use
For a Coca-Cola sign of unknown age, make a short record while everything is still in front of you. Start with the slogan, diameter or face dimensions, back, edges, and all holes. Include whether it’s convex or flat, the exact graphic layout, and any store history. One way to keep everything straight is to capture a side-on shot that shows the shape without distorting the front view. Preserve each image at its original size. Wide shots establish context, and close-ups let someone zoom in on the details that are too small to read in the wide shot.
If you have more than one piece, give each one a simple number and use it in the photo filenames or in your message. Keep any paperwork with the matching item. Be especially clear about shared slogans across different productions and fresh paint hiding condition. Write down who told you the history and when, and mark dates or attributions you’re unsure about. That gives a buyer something specific to follow up on when a photo raises a question.
When several pieces are involved, a single message can introduce the collection and list the items you’re ready to sell. Follow it with the clearest photos of the most promising piece. You can send additional details as requested. If timing matters, mention when you need a decision and whether the items have to be moved by that date. An early conversation is easier if the owner can still check a measurement or photograph a label.
Compare completed sales before choosing a price
Start with the exact kind of item you have. In this category, you might encounter a round convex button, a rectangular tin sign, and a porcelain store sign. Those are separate starting points for research. For each plausible match, write down its measurements, material, condition, sale date, and any detail that explains a difference from your example. Keep the link and a note about where the price came from, so you can revisit the comparison later.
Ask whether the number represents a completed sale, an active listing, or an estimate. In an auction result, check whether the figure is the winning bid alone or includes the buyer’s premium. If you’re deciding whether to sell, consider what you would receive after fees, packing, and transport. Keep prices in their original units and use the actual sale date when comparing older results with recent ones.
When the closest match has an important difference, write it in plain language. It might be a smaller example, a different mounting style, or an unusually complete piece. Avoid applying a fixed discount without evidence. Two or three imperfect matches can still help a buyer explain a range if the differences are visible. If the sale history is thin, the photos and ownership history become especially useful.
Look for condition differences across the whole face
Study the piece in indirect daylight. On a button, look around the rim and across the curved face for bends or areas that interrupt the profile. On a flat sign, compare the color in exposed areas with the portion that sat under a bracket or frame. Take close-ups without filters and include a wide view so a buyer can locate the damage. A sign described as slightly faded might have even color loss or a large pale strip on one side. Those can look very different on display.
An example from a seller’s point of view
Here’s a hypothetical example. An estate owner finds two red Coca-Cola pieces with a similar script, one a convex button and one a flat wall sign. At first, the seller has enough information to start looking online but still has several details to confirm. Rather than relying on the first result, they photograph each separately and compare shape, dimensions, and material before looking at prices. The payoff is practical. The two pieces can be researched individually instead of inheriting one another’s value.
One piece has a little printed line near the rim. The other has extra screw holes through the graphic and a different back finish. Including those differences in the description makes it easier for a buyer to identify which documented listing is a realistic comparison for each piece.
What to photograph for an appraisal
- Include a side view to show whether the Coca-Cola sign is flat or curved.
- Take straight-on photos of the front and back where you can reach them safely.
- Add close-ups of the edges, mounting holes, marks, and any damage or repairs.
- Send dimensions, your location, and any history you can document.
Frequently asked questions
How do I measure a Coca-Cola button?
Measure across the face at its widest point. Include a side profile and note any separate brackets or hardware.
Does a faded red face rule out collector interest?
Fading is one condition factor. Buyers also consider the exact design, material, scarcity, and whether the piece has been repainted.
How do I describe a sign if I don’t know whether it’s porcelain?
Send close-ups of chips and edges and a full back photo. Describe the surface as it appears without guessing at the material.
What should I include when I ask for an appraisal?
Start with the slogan, diameter or face dimensions, back, edges, and all holes. In your message, include whether it’s convex or flat, the exact graphic layout, and any store history. State where the piece is and whether you’re looking for a valuation, interested in selling, or both. For multiple pieces, start with an overview so we can tell which photos go together.
Can I get a useful estimate from one photo?
A front photo is enough to start the conversation. A buyer may need the back, dimensions, markings, and condition details before giving a meaningful estimate. If you can get only one view safely, send it and explain where the sign is mounted or stored.
Do identical slogans mean two signs were made at the same time?
A slogan may have been used across several designs and production runs. Compare maker’s marks, shape, and dimensions as well.
Where should I look for small print on a button?
Check around the rim and lower face. Include a side photo so the shape and edge construction are visible.
Should I touch up faded lettering before selling?
Document the finish as found and ask for an estimate first. An evaluator can explain how existing wear affects the comparison.
Get a vintage sign appraisal
If you think your sign was made before 1970, text photos of both sides, close-ups of markings, and dimensions to 916-817-9625. See how to get your sign appraised.
Related vintage sign guides
guide to dating porcelain gas station signs, estate sale sign appraisal checklist


